Dicky Saputra, a student of the Law Study Program in the Faculty of Sharia and Law at UIN Sunan Kalijaga Yogyakarta, filed a judicial review of Law No. 20 of 2025 on the Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP) with the Constitutional Court (MK). The petition challenged the wording of Article 215 of the KUHAP concerning the prohibition on asking entrapping questions of a witness, an expert, or a defendant.
In Decision No. 383/PUU-XXIV/2026, read on Thursday, November 12, 2026, in the MK Plenary Courtroom in Jakarta, the Court granted part of the petition. The Court declared that the word "Expert" (Ahli) in Article 215 of the KUHAP is contrary to the 1945 Constitution and has no binding legal force.
With this decision, Article 215 of the KUHAP now reads in full: "Entrapping questions are prohibited from being asked of a Witness or Defendant."
In his petition, Dicky challenged the use of the phrase "Saksi Ahli, atau Terdakwa" (literally "Expert Witness, or Defendant") in Article 215. He argued that the placement of a comma after the word "Ahli" and the absence of a separator between "Saksi" (witness) and "Ahli" (expert) could lead to different interpretations of the provision.
According to Dicky, if the provision is read narrowly, the prohibition on entrapping questions applies only to experts and defendants. That reading could remove protection for witnesses from entrapping questions during the examination of criminal cases.
The petitioner also argued that the wording of Article 215 does not meet the principle of clarity of formulation required by Article 5(f) of Law No. 12 of 2011 on the Formation of Laws and Regulations. Yet the KUHAP already distinguishes the definitions of a witness and an expert in Article 1, points 47 and 51.
In its legal reasoning, the Court held that Article 215 of the 2025 KUHAP has the same substance as Article 166 of Law No. 8 of 1981 on the earlier KUHAP. The old provision expressly stated that entrapping questions must not be asked of a defendant or a witness.
Constitutional Justice Liliek Prisbawono Adi explained that in the 2025 KUHAP, the legislators changed the wording by inserting the phrase "Saksi Ahli." However, the use of that term was not accompanied by further explanation in the Elucidation of Article 215 of the KUHAP.
"This means that the Elucidation of Article 215 of Law 20/2025 essentially prohibits entrapping questions only for witnesses or defendants, and the Elucidation of Article 215 of Law 20/2025 does not mention or describe anything relating to experts at all," Liliek said as he read the Court's legal considerations.
Constitutional Justice M. Guntur Hamzah, who continued reading the legal considerations, explained that the 2025 KUHAP does not recognize the nomenclature "expert witness" (saksi ahli) except in Article 215. Yet, doctrinally, witnesses and experts have different meanings and positions in criminal proceedings.
A witness is a person who gives information about a criminal event that he or she heard, saw, or experienced personally, or a person who has and/or controls data or information related to the case under examination. An expert, meanwhile, is a person who has special knowledge, experience, or skills in a particular field related to a criminal case.
According to the Court, combining the two terms into one nomenclature may cause confusion and ambiguity about the meaning, existence, and position of each in legal proceedings.
"Based on these legal facts, viewed through grammatical, systematic, and historical interpretation, particularly in relation to the essence found in the norm of the old Article 166 of the KUHAP and its Elucidation and the Elucidation of Article 215 of Law 20/2025, that the prohibition on asking entrapping questions is directed only at witnesses or defendants, the Court holds that the existence of the norm in Article 215 of Law 20/2025, which contains the phrase 'Saksi Ahli,' is inappropriate and potentially causes confusion and legal uncertainty," Guntur said.
The Court also considered the principle of clarity of formulation in drafting laws and regulations. Every legal provision must use clear word choices, terms, structure, and legal language so that it does not give rise to multiple interpretations when applied.
On those grounds, the Court declared that the word "Ahli" is not relevant to keep in Article 215 of the KUHAP. Its removal is needed to provide legal certainty and to keep the norm consistent with the substance of the provision in the earlier KUHAP.
Dicky's judicial review is one form of student participation in testing legal norms through constitutional mechanisms. The issue, which began from the wording of an article in the KUHAP, was brought to a law-review forum to obtain an assessment of its conformity with the constitution.
Dicky's petition also adds to the record of UIN Sunan Kalijaga students taking part in judicial review at the Constitutional Court. Earlier, four UIN Sunan Kalijaga students filed a petition to review the presidential threshold provision, which drew wide attention from the national media. These two cases, on different issues, show students' involvement in testing legal norms, safeguarding constitutional principles, and taking part in the dynamics of Indonesian constitutional law. (humassk)