Dicky Saputra, a student in the Law Study Program at the Faculty of Sharia and Law, UIN Sunan Kalijaga Yogyakarta, filed a petition for judicial review of Article 215 of Law No. 20 of 2025 on the Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP) with the Constitutional Court (MK). As the sole petitioner, he challenged the absence of a comma between the words "Saksi" (witness) and "Ahli" (expert) in the phrase "Saksi Ahli, atau Terdakwa." According to Dicky, this wording creates uncertainty about who is protected from entrapping questions in criminal trials.
The Constitutional Court partially granted Dicky's petition in Decision No. 383/PUU-XXIV/2026, delivered on Thursday (11/12/2026) in the MK Plenary Courtroom in Jakarta. The Court declared that the word "Ahli," in Article 215 of the KUHAP is contrary to the 1945 Constitution and has no binding legal force. With this decision, Article 215 now reads, "Entrapping questions are prohibited from being posed to a Witness or Defendant."
In an interview with the UIN Sunan Kalijaga Public Relations Office, Dicky said he came across the problem while studying the new KUHAP as a guide for simulating criminal trials in a national moot court competition. He noticed that the comma was placed after the word "Ahli," while "Saksi" and "Ahli" were written side by side. In a list, Dicky said, a comma separates the items being named.
"Who exactly is meant to be protected from entrapping questions? Is it the witness, the expert, or the defendant? Or is it an expert witness or the defendant?" Dicky said.
According to Dicky, writing the words without a separator allows "Saksi Ahli" to be read as a single term, even though the KUHAP defines witnesses and experts separately. This led him to explore the possibility of a drafting error in Article 215. As a student of legislation, he believes clear wording is necessary so the provision can be understood and applied consistently.
Dicky also tied his petition to a shift in approach within criminal procedure law. In his view, the enactment of the new KUHAP reflects a move from the crime control model, which emphasizes controlling crime and handling cases quickly, toward the due process model, which emphasizes protecting rights in judicial proceedings. He believes this protection must be reflected in clearly worded provisions, including who is protected from entrapping questions.
"This new KUHAP places witnesses and defendants as subjects with equal standing in the criminal justice system. So their rights must also be protected and respected," Dicky said.
Dicky said he began drafting the petition in early October 2026. It took him about a week to prepare the document before submitting it to the Court. Because he was unable to attend in person in Jakarta, he asked to participate in the hearings online.
After his petition was registered, Dicky took part in a preliminary hearing to present the main points of his petition. He received feedback from the panel of judges and was given about a week to revise the document. At the second hearing, he presented the main points of the revisions.
He estimates that the entire process, from starting to draft the petition to the delivery of the decision, took about a month and a half.
Reflecting on this remarkable experience, Dicky said his coursework at UIN Sunan Kalijaga helped him understand the procedures for filing a judicial review, from drafting the petition to preparing evidence. He deepened those skills through the Moot Court Community, particularly in drafting the posita (the grounds and reasons for the petition) and making sure those reasons align with the petitum (what the petitioner asks the Court to decide).
"I learned it in my courses, and then my learning was reinforced through the Moot Court Community," he said.
The review of Article 215 of the KUHAP was Dicky's first petition to the Constitutional Court. He said his original goal was to learn the judicial review process firsthand, so he did not expect the Court to grant part of his petition.
"My original intention in filing this petition was just to learn," Dicky said.
From this experience, Dicky encourages fellow students to read laws critically. He also urges them to become familiar with the review mechanism at the Constitutional Court when they find provisions they believe harm their constitutional rights. (humassk)